Our parish is planning to renovate the church proper. Presently we sit in a semi-circle around the altar and there are 3 aisles. The two main entrance doors open onto either side of the sanctuary so basically the church is backwards. When you are sitting in the church facing the altar you can see everyone that goes in and out. The distractions of seeing everyone around you and everyone going in and out are enormous. The theory behind this configuration was that it would more adequately demonstrate that the parish is "gathering around the table of the Lord."
Sorry, but I come to Mass to worship God and receive Jesus, not eyeball my neighbour and I don't give two figs about any tables - give me the altar!
We had a display set up after Mass so people could voice their concerns/comments to us about the impending changes which will move the sanctuary so that only the priest can see those coming in and out. The only people who are upset about this change are the 60+ crowd. They are so hung up on the "JIP" factor (Jesus In the People.)
I realize many of them were impressionable 20 - 35 year olds caught up in the social upheaval of the 60's when our present church building was designed. They were open to silly novelties in an attempt to escape the superstitions and oppressiveness that at times characterized the pre-Vatican II church. They wanted more "luv" and less guilt. I get that. However, they seem to be missing the boat.
One lady opined that the "roundness" brings unity. Obviously she hasn't attended a parish council meeting in the last year! Apparently she doesn't see that our parish is split into three factions - the rad trads, the happy-clappy hippies and the apathetic pew warmers. The trads want the change, the hippies don't and the pew warmers could care less either way.
Our unity must come from our focus and understanding of the Eucharist. I've been in the traditional "one central aisle/kneelers intact" kind of churches and they were less reverent than we are in my "round" church. However - a round church does up the "JIP" factor.
So, aside from telling this lady that her theology sucks - what can I say to help her realize that our focus should be the tabernacle, the crucifix and the altar? In her eyes these things are more visible to all in the current setting especially since the set up means there are no more than 10 rows of pews per section. We'll easily double that after the renovation. She thinks that the current seating also helps kids pay attention during Mass. Honestly, with three weekend Masses we are lucky if 40 kids show up and most of them are in the cry room.
Help me to help her understand that a Christocentric focus is more important than looking at each other over the "dinner table."
PS...there is no option for me to leave my parish - I live in a very small town and I'd have to travel 40 miles to the next town to find another Catholic church.
+++